IYC Ed: Monitoring of social media (or any other) smacks of cold war treatment in communist countries, but is a very real need today, not least for children’s protection. Is this snooping, the same as looking at kids diaries when you were growing up, necessary? A good thing? Intrusive? Tell us what you think.
by Lisa Vaas on July 31, 2015 | 6 Comments
Filed Under: Facebook, Featured, Law & order, Privacy, Social networks, Twitter
Does your child ever tweet that she”hates” her math teacher?
Does he write that he’s so embarrassed he could jump off a bridge?
Do her posts ever mention being bullied, or does she use them to make fun of other kids?
Are you, as a parent, even aware of everything your kids post?
Even if you aren’t on top of everything your child posts, your kid’s school well might be, given all the social media monitoring software on the market.
If you live in Florida’s Orange County, those kind of posts could mean school officials come looking into whatever’s going on.
That’s because Orange County is one of the latest school districts to start monitoring all of the thousands of social media posts made by both students and teachers.
It’s doing so with a new monitoring software called Snaptrends that monitors social media posts from all accounts in its location.
The school district reportedly paid $14,000 for a one-year Snaptrends license.
That buys the district’s schools the ability to search thousands of posts on sites like Twitter, Facebook and Instagram, hunting for keywords that might indicate trouble.
School officials say that the goal is to flag potential dangers including cyberbullying, suicide and crime.
Joie Cadle of the Orange County School Board told WESH TV that the monitoring will alert school administrators to kids sending potentially serious threats via social media:
If they are sitting in a classroom and they are tweeting because they are mad at their teacher or their girlfriend for whatever reason, and there are some threatening words there, we need to be able to know if it is credible.
But opponents of the school’s new snooping effort, which was announced in April, say it’s not the fact that their kids are being surveilled that’s disturbing them.
Rather, it’s the unanswered question of just what, exactly the school district plans to do with the information it collects.
WESH TV quotes Cindy Hamilton, co-founder of Opt Out Orlando:
My privacy issues aren’t with the fact that they’re just out there looking at it, because frankly, with social media it’s not private. But what are they going to do with the information they look at? That’s what we’re concerned about.
When it announced the monitoring, the school district said it will:[U]se the software to conduct routine monitoring for purposes of prevention or early intervention of potential issues where students or staff could be at risk to themselves or to others.
The company will assist district law enforcement and security personnel in monitoring publicly available social media communications that are relevant to school operations and personnel.
Florida isn’t the only state to turn to monitoring in the face of school shootings, violence and bullying.
As CNN reported last year, the school system in Huntsville, Alabama, hired a retired FBI agent for security work, which included reviewing social media”when a high priority tip is received about an emerging threat to a school, student or staff member,” as a school district spokesman said.
As well, the Glendale school district in Los Angeles in 2012 made the controversial decision to pay the firm Geo Listening $40,500 to monitor its students’ social media activity on sites like Twitter, Facebook and Instagram.
The impetus to look into the technology was the suicides of two students. The final decision to pay for the monitoring was made after a pilot program helped administrators step in when yet another student used social media to talk about”ending his life.”
The Orange County School District hasn’t detailed how officials will decide what, precisely, to review.
Some technologies might just search social media posts, but others are more akin to tools you might expect to see in the arsenals of government surveillance agencies.
Safe Outlook Corporation’s monitoring software CompuGuardian, for example, gives school administrators not only the ability to search keywords connected to cyberbullying and drug use, but also to delve into students’ search histories to see if they’re researching topics about dangers such as school violence.
CNN quotes Safe Outlook President David Jones:
You can identify a student, and you can jump into their activity logs and see exactly what they’ve typed, exactly where they’ve gone, exactly what they’ve done, and it gives you some history that you can go back to that child and use some disciplinary action.
You can bring in the parent and say,’Hey, look, this is what your child’s doing. You need to talk to them about it.’
Interestingly enough, and hardly surprising, is the fact that Snaptrends is reportedly also in use by the Central Florida Intelligence Exchange, which is the local law enforcement Fusion Center.
A Fusion Center is a center set up to”analyze information and identify trends to share timely intelligence with federal, state, and local law enforcement including [Department of Homeland Security], which then further shares this information with other members of the Intelligence Community.”
As such, it’s not surprising that, just like with the Feds’ propensity to amass vast troves of surveillance data about citizens, so too are opponents pointing to monitoring software’s collection of anything and everything, including both potentially threatening or perfectly innocent content.
From a post against the surveillance, written by Florida attorney Scott Martin:
Snaptrends is a type of social media scraper/aggregator that collects social media information in mass. The data are scooped up by an automated process without regard to the nature of the content – good, bad, or indifferent.
But what guarantees are there that the social media information collected by the District will be limited to… benevolent purposes? What policies are in place? Who can access the data? What conclusions are being drawn from the data? Who is drawing those conclusions? What standards are they using in making decisions based on captured data?
All these questions should be answered before any such tool is put in place, Martin says.
Jake · 22 days ago
Great article here. I wonder what the process will be with parental notifications and potential legal consequences for the parents themselves. Also, I don’t hear the EFF complaining about this – go figure. Reply
Joe · 20 days ago
Great. I remember when we used to joke about Russian and Cuban informants spying on citizens. Old and Jaded. Back to the USSA. Reply
thispageinetntionallyleftblank · 19 days ago
It is time to go dark, to go offline, and leave the matrix. The purpose of the internet is to allow corporations and governments the power to spy on people. Reply
MayVaneDay · 19 days ago
Couldn’t a student subvert this kind of surveillance by not putting a location on their profile, using a pseudonym, and using Tor or a VPN if allowed on the network? Reply
Cab Essen · 18 days ago
The US Department of Education needs to enforce privacy protections under FERPA for any data that schools collect on students. Reply
Grumpy · 17 days ago
I agree that if these tactics are put into place – that should happen AFTER well thought out policies are published. I also suppose that the next step will be that the students will be forced to”register” their social media accounts with the school?
I suppose that we should consider social media posts as being”shouted from the rooftops” as opposed to”whispered in the corner”.
Other Posts that you may be interest in;
- How to Use HootSuite for Social Media Monitoring – Performancing – In the course of just a few years, social media marketing has skyrocketed to become the new go-to way to effectively get word out about your business without breaking the bank. However, that doesn’t mean a mere presence on Facebook and Twitter is going to get the job done. Once you start leveraging some of the newer players, such as Pinterest, Instagram, and Tumblr, you may find your market presence growing at unprecedented rates.
- 23 Tools for Social Media Monitoring | Practical Ecommerce – Here is a list of tools for social media monitoring. Listen to multiple networks from a single dashboard, receive alerts when you’re mentioned, or even keep tabs on a competitor. Track your social media stats, and discover what …
- Oxbow Social Media Monitoring | tapps.net – Oxbow Social Media Monitoring was founded with one clear goal in mind: to proactively address the issues and challenges that can arise when children use social media. The life-changing implications of bullying, oversharing …
- Social Media Monitoring Business case: Dynatrace – Digimind – Social Media Monitoring Business case: Dynatrace. Dynatrace, a digital performance monitoring company, uses Digimind Social to identify users and their needs, on top of benchmarking themselves against their competitors. As a data driven …
- The new social media monitoring software for Instagram – Instagram offers wonderful pictures to embed in your articles and that are relevant to the actual news. This is the preferred social networks for celebrities who don’t know how to write. But you do, so… Instagram social media monitoring …